Dynadot

Sue for a domain registered before trademark?

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch

Ian Goh

Established Member
Impact
288
As the title suggest. Lets say a domain registered, e.g FunnyBooks.com

A few years later a company registered FunnyBookz.com and apply for the trademark for that name.

The name is sold to another company and not FunnyBookz.

FunnyBookz sue the other company for buying Funnybooks.com

Is that possible?
 
0
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
No. No one even companies will not sue someone when they know that they have little or no chance for win that case (because suing is expensive and also imagine if someone is from different country they need to spend a lot of money for suing and if they lose the case they need to do damage compensation so...)
 
1
•••
@silgro12 anything is possible in the world of 'Law'

@Ian Goh I would imagine that it *could* be possible if the company that bought funnybooks/com used it in a way that harmed the other company that owned the funnybookz TM.

in any case though, it's the buying company's responsibility and not yours (ie. the seller's) since they should have made their research before buying a potentially TMed name.

I should note however that all 'law' questions should be asked to a professional. Whatever we say here in the forum can never be considered as a legitimate answer to such questions.
 
2
•••
@silgro12 anything is possible in the world of 'Law'

@Ian Goh I would imagine that it *could* be possible if the company that bought funnybooks/com used it in a way that harmed the other company that owned the funnybookz TM.

in any case though, it's the buying company's responsibility and not yours (ie. the seller's) since they should have made their research before buying a potentially TMed name.

I should note however that all 'law' questions should be asked to a professional. Whatever we say here in the forum can never be considered as a legitimate answer to such questions.
Im a law student so I know a little bit about law :) When they sue you and they lose you can only benefit from being sued because they need to pay you all damages they caused by suing and also if you have a good lawyer you can say that you have suffered mental pain or miss some job opportunities because of trial and so on. Also, you have good reasons for defend: 1. you registrated domain before they protect their name or product so you couldnt "see in the future" then and know what will happened for few monthes or years 2. you are posessing only domain name which can be used in different way for expample they sell their books on their page and you can develop your domain and make webiste with funny quotes or some library when people can search some comedian books or something so you dont copy them...

But yes everything is possible but I think you cant lose this case with a "normal" lawyer :P
 
2
•••
Im a law student so I know a little bit about law :) When they sue you and they lose you can only benefit from being sued because they need to pay you all damages they caused by suing and also if you have a good lawyer you can say that you have suffered mental pain or miss some job opportunities because of trial and so on. Also, you have good reasons for defend: 1. you registrated domain before they protect their name or product so you couldnt "see in the future" then and know what will happened for few monthes or years 2. you are posessing only domain name which can be used in different way for expample they sell their books on their page and you can develop your domain and make webiste with funny quotes or some library when people can search some comedian books or something so you dont copy them...

But yes everything is possible but I think you cant lose this case with a "normal" lawyer :P

That's good info to know.

Bear in mind though that we're not talking about the seller being sued rather than the buyer. As soon as the buyer gets hold of the name it's considered infringement (apologies if this is not the correct word in english) since they acquired the name *after* the TM registration.
 
1
•••
That's good info to know.

Bear in mind though that we're not talking about the seller being sued rather than the buyer. As soon as the buyer gets hold of the name it's considered infringement (apologies if this is not the correct word in english) since they acquired the name *after* the TM registration.
Well, can they sue the company which buy FunnyBooks.com? Yes, they can. Can they win this case? it depends. We dont know what the buyer will do with that domain name. If I am the lawyer and FunnyBookz come to me and want to sue the buyer of the FunnyBooks.com, I would say: Wait until we see what the owner of FunnyBooks.com will do with this domain and how he will develop domain name and if website will be harmful for FunnyBookz, then we will have strong evidence for sueing him.

But, also there are many lawyers whos only chase the money and they dont care if their contract will win the case
 
1
•••
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back